The 4 food dehydrators we'd put on our counter in 2026Top 4 dehydrators of 2026 → See the ranking

Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator Review

On paper, the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator gets the important things right: a compact 5-tray size, stainless steel trays and temperature control from 95 to 167°F. It earned a spot in our top 4 food dehydrators, and it's built for anyone who makes jerky more often than fruit chips.

Specifications
BrandMagic Mill
CategoryFood dehydrators
Trays5, as stated in the listing
Heater wattage240 W, as stated in the listing
Listing noteSeller features state 5 included trays. Usable area and actual drying performance are separate checks.
Temperature range95-167°F
Timerup to 48 hours
Tray materialStainless steel
Buyer reviews4,962 · 4.4/5
ASINB08M4FD4WR
Price$59.991

1 Price on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed

Full listing title: Magic Mill Food Dehydrator Machine | 5 Stackable Stainless Steel Trays, 48H Digital Adjustable Timer & Temperature Control Upto 167° Electric Dryer & Preserver for Jerky, Fruit, Dog Treats & Much More

Listing evidence
Trays5 Stackable Stainless Steel Trays Listing title
Heater wattage240W Listing feature bullet
Updated October 2026
Exact listing, ASIN B08M4FD4WR
Rated with a published method

Compared with similar dehydrators

The two picks next to it in our food dehydrators ranking, with their rating and a dated price.

Compare side by side ↗

Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator

Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator

8.3Very good · out of 10$59.99Price on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed
  • Stated: 5 trays · 240 W
  • 4,962 buyer reviews
  • Food dehydrators
This product ↑
COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator

COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator

9.4Excellent · out of 10$143.96-10%List price $159.99Save $16.03 vs. list pricePrice on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed
  • Stated: 6 trays · 600 W
  • 21,529 buyer reviews
  • Food dehydrators
See the review ↗
Excalibur Select 5-Tray Dehydrator

Excalibur Select 5-Tray Dehydrator

8.1Very good · out of 10$129.99Price on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed
  • Stated: 5 trays
  • Food dehydrators
See the review ↗

5 trays

That's the tray count the listing gives, all stainless steel. A compact size for weekly snacks. The listing doesn't give the drying area, so ask for the tray size if you plan big batches.

Why it made our list

What changes on drying day

5 trays. A compact size for weekly snacks, so it doesn't take over the counter.

Stainless steel trays. Steel racks won't stain orange after a tomato batch or hang on to last week's garlic.

95-167°F. Low enough for basil and mint, hot enough for meat. Follow your jerky method for the heat step.

Weekly snacks or harvest season?

For weekly snacks, 5 trays hold a bag of sliced apples or a good bunch of herbs per run.

For harvest season, the 48-hour timer covers long overnight runs.

On paper it leans toward everyday snacks.

Great for you if…

  • You want to try drying without giving up half the counter
  • You'd rather not dry food on plastic
  • You dry herbs and want a gentle low setting
  • You trust a long track record: 4,962 buyer reviews

Skip it if…

  • You want a rear-mounted fan: this listing doesn't state one
  • You simply want our top pick: that's the COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator (9.4/10)

Living with it

On the counter

The Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator is a countertop size, so it can live in a corner or come out of the cupboard on drying day. A batch can run all day, so pick a corner away from the kettle and the toaster.

Drying day

Set it to anywhere from 95 to 167°F and start the 48-hour timer.

Clean-up

Steel racks don't stain or hold smells.

What Magic Mill promises

The seller states, word for word, in the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator listing:

  • This Fruit and Herb Dehydrator features five (5) food-grade adjustable trays that allow you to dry different foods, fruits, and veggies at once.
  • Our Meat Dehydrator comes with premium stainless steel trays that passed the quality check and industry standards for food safety.
  • You can set it between 95-167°F for up to 48:00 hours – depending on your food dehydration requirements.
  • To clean, simply remove the trays from the machine and wash them using soapy water or through a dishwasher.

Their words and their figures, straight from the listing. How evenly it dries is something no listing can tell you.

Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator, view 3

What buyers say

Buyers give it 4.4/5, a strong record, right on this ranking's 4.4 average. And with 4,962 reviews behind it, that number is hard to argue with.

The numbers
Buyer rating
4.4/5
Reviews
4,962
This ranking's average
4.4/5

Capacity, controls and what's in the box

What the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator listing names:

  • 5 trays
  • 95-167°F
  • Timer up to 48 hours
  • 240 W heater
  • Stainless steel trays

Measure the spot on your counter, plus the air gap the manual asks for, before you order.

Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator, view 4

The one thing we'd check first

If we were buying the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator, we'd check the tray size first: 5 trays are stated but not the drying area, and that is what decides your batch.

Before you buy

Your batch

5 trays are stated, but not their size. Tray count alone doesn't give you the drying area, so ask for the tray dimensions. Our tray planner turns them into a batch.

Your counter

Measure the spot and leave the air gap the manual asks for around it: a batch runs for hours.

Heat and meat

95-167°F is stated. For jerky, follow a validated method (USDA or NCHFP) for the heat step: the dial alone doesn't make meat safe.

Cleaning

Ask which parts can go in the dishwasher, and whether the trays fit in your sink.

Price and availability

On Nov 18, 2026 the listing showed $59.99. That puts it in the cheaper third of the 81 food dehydrators we have a recent price for.

The button opens the exact listing (ASIN B08M4FD4WR), where today's price, stock and seller apply.

The price
Price
$59.99Price on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed
Among 81 food dehydrators
Cheaper third

A better dehydrator for you?

Bigger batches? The OLIXIS 8-Tray 500W Steel Dehydrator (7.4/10) gives 8.2 ft² of drying space.

Tired of rotating trays? The Elite Gourmet Steel-Tray Dehydrator (8.6/10) states a rear-mounted fan.

Running it overnight near the bedroom? The COSORI 350W 5-Tray Food Dehydrator (8.5/10) states under 47 dB.

How it compares

How the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator stacks up against the closest alternative in our ranking, the COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator.

CriterionMagic Mill 5-Tray Steel DehydratorCOSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator
Our rating8.3/109.4/10
Trays56
Temperature95-167°F95-165°F
Rear fanNot statedStated
Heater240 W600 W
Buyer reviews4,962 · 4.4/521,529 · 4.7/5
Price$59.991$143.961 -10% List price $159.99

1 Price on Nov 18, 2026 · may have changed

Pick the COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator if you want our higher-rated option (9.4/10), with 6 trays and a rear fan; stay with the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator for a top setting of 167°F.

Our take

The verdict

8.3Very good · out of 10

Our favorite thing about the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator is a compact 5-tray size, closely followed by stainless steel trays. 4,962 buyers back that up with 4.4/5, about as reassuring as a review record gets. Honestly, the catch: no rear fan in the listing, where most rivals here state one. We'd pick this Magic Mill food dehydrator if you want to try drying without giving up half the counter; otherwise, put it next to the COSORI CP267-FD 6-Tray Dehydrator first.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator any good?

We rate it 8.3/10 (very good), #2 of 4 in our food dehydrator ranking. It is based on 4,962 buyer reviews averaging 4.4/5 and the specifications stated in the listing.

What do you get with the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator?

Its listing states a compact 5-tray size, stainless steel trays, a 95-167°F range, a 48-hour timer, a 240 W heater and digital controls. Those are the seller's figures; how evenly it dries can't be read from a listing.

What should I check before ordering the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator?

Your batch: 5 trays are stated, but not their size. Tray count alone doesn't give you the drying area, so ask for the tray dimensions. Our tray planner turns them into a batch. Your counter: measure the spot and leave the air gap the manual asks for around it: a batch runs for hours. Heat and meat: 95-167°F is stated. For jerky, follow a validated method (USDA or NCHFP) for the heat step: the dial alone doesn't make meat safe. Cleaning: ask which parts can go in the dishwasher, and whether the trays fit in your sink.

Where can I buy the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator?

We link to the exact listing on Amazon, where today's price, stock and seller apply. It is an affiliate link, and it has no effect on the rating.

Keep comparing

If the Magic Mill 5-Tray Steel Dehydrator hasn't sold you yet, see where it ranks, read the guides that feature it or browse all food dehydrators.

Where it ranks

Read this before you buy